The House on Punchbowl Hill





















Dead Men Tell


Twentieth Century-Fox Film Corporation
Distributed: Twentieth Century-Fox Film Corporation, May 28, 1941
Production: Mid-December 1940 to mid-January 1941
Copyright: Twentieth Century-Fox Film Corporation, March 28, 1941: LP10394
Film: Black and white
Length: 6 reels, 5,383 or 5,441 feet
Running Time: 60-61 minutes
Production Code Administration Certificate Number: 6981
Source: Based on the character "Charlie Chan" created by Earl Derr Biggers


Associate Producers: Walter Morosco and Ralph Dietrich
Director: Harry Lachman
Assistant Director: Saul Wurzel (not credited)
Original Screenplay: John Larkin
Director of Photography: Charles Clarke
Art Direction: Richard Day and Lewis Creber
Set Decorations: Thomas Little  
Film Editor: Harry Reynolds
Costumes: Herschel
Sound: Alfred Bruzlin and Harry M. Leonard
Musical Direction: Emil Newman
Publicity Director: Harry Brand (not credited)  

CAST:

Sidney Toler: Charlie Chan
Shiela Ryan: Kate Ransome
Robert Weldon: Steve Daniels
Sen Yung: Jimmy Chan
Don Douglas: Jed Thomasson
Katharine Aldridge: Laura Thursday
Paul McGrath: Charles Thursday (also known as Mr. Parks)
George Reeves: Bill Lydig
Truman Bradley: Captain Kane
Ethel Griffies: Miss [Patience] Nodbury
Lenita Lane: Dr. Anne Bonney
Milton Parsons: Gene LaFarge
Lee Tung Foo: Wu Mei (not credited)
Ralph Dunn: Homicide Desk Sergeant (not credited)
Lee Phelps: Detective (not credited)
Stanley Andrews: Inspector Vesey (not credited)
Pat Flaherty: Policeman (not credited)
Tim Ryan: Red Eye [Bartender] (not credited)
Jimmy Aubrey: English Sailor (not credited)
John Wallace: Peg Leg (not credited)
Charles Tannen: Sailor (not credited)
O.G. "Dutch" Hendrian: Saloon Dancer  



SUMMARY:

On the night before his sailing ship, the Suva Star is to leave for Cocos Island on a treasure hunt, Captain Kane discusses the journey's sponsor, Miss Patience Nodbury, with Steve Daniels, who had helped to arrange the trip.

Charlie Chan, searching for his son, Jimmy, who is attempting to stow away in search of adventure, arrives. He meets Miss Nodbury who explains that she tore the treasure map, drawn by her pirate grandfather, Matthew Nodbury, known as Black Hook, into four pieces, and gave three of them to other passengers, adding that someone has tried to steal her portion of the map, causing her to delay the start of the trip. She goes on to tell Chan that Black Hook, who had a peg leg and a hook, appears to each Nodbury as they are about to die.

Later, as Miss Nodbury retires to her cabin, she hears the approaching tap of Black Hook's peg leg and then the scratching of his hook upon her door. As the elderly woman opens the door, she sees her ancestor and dies of a heart attack. As Miss Nodbury lies dead on the floor, the pirate's hook snatches up her piece of the treasure map.

Meanwhile, the ship's passengers, claiming that they have received a mysterious message from Steve Daniels, arrive and are introduced to Chan. They include Bill Lydig, a journalist about whom Chan is curious because he had heard that Lydig was dead, collector of rare coins Jed Thomasson, typist Kate Ransome, and newlyweds Charles and Laura Thursday.

Kate discovers Miss Nodbury's body, after which Chan finds part of a Black Hook disguise that someone had worn to frighten the old woman to death.

When Chan sends Jimmy ashore to call the police, the youngster overhears a suspicious conversation between Dr. Anne Bonney, a psychoanalyst, and her patient, Gene La Farge, who are both passengers aboard the Suva Star.

Back on the ship, La Farge admits that he had seen Miss Nodbury's body, but he denies that he had anything to do with her death. Laura Thursday and Jed Thomasson give their pieces of the treasure map to Chan for safekeeping, after which Jimmy finds the rest of the pirate disguise as well as another portion of the map in Steve Daniels' cabin. Steve protests that he is being framed, and it is then discovered that the two pieces of the map in Chan's possession have been stolen. The group then finds Kate, who had fainted after reading in a magazine that Lydig is really an escaped murderer. Before Lydig can be questioned, however, he is found dead of suffocation inside of a diving bell below deck.

Chan then goes ashore to find Captain Kane, who states that he has not met any of the passengers yet. When Chan questions the captain about his strange behavior, Kane explains that many years ago, he had gone on a treasure hunt to Cocos Island with a partner, but that the man had stranded him there, leaving him to die. Believing that this former partner would not be able to resist returning to the island to seek out the treasure, Kane had arranged for and publicized the journey so that he could find and kill the man who had tried to kill him.
CONCLUSION:

After Chan calls the police, Inspector Vesey arrives and arrests Daniels because of the circumstantial evidence against him. Chan, who has the map piece that was found in Daniels' cabin, uses himself as bait to catch the killer. Chan, accompanied on the dock by La Farge, is stalked by the person who is dressed as Black Hook. Jimmy, who was supposed to signal his pop at the approach of danger, has difficulty doing so, as he has fallen into the water.

Confronted by the killer, Chan unmasks him, revealing the face of Jed Thomasson, who explains that it was Lydig who had stolen the pieces of the map from Chan, and that he had killed him to get them. As Thomasson is about to kill the detective and La Farge, he is overcome by Captain Kane who reveals that it was Thomasson who had been his partner who had left him for dead on Cocos Island. Inspector Vesey and the police arrive, arresting Thomasson and taking him away.

The film ends with Jimmy once again falling into the bay as he had throughout the picture. An amused Charlie Chan tells his number two son, "Honolulu directly west."

NOTES: According to Hollywood Reporter news items, Jean Rogers was to have appeared in this film as Laura Thursday, but was replaced after shooting began by Katherine Aldridge when she became ill with the flu. Hollywood Reporter production charts include Faye Helm in the cast, but her participation in the completed film has not been confirmed.

Adapted from: AMERICAN FILM INSTITUTE CATALOG - Within Our Gates: Ethnicity in American Feature Films, 1911-1960



CHARLIE CHAN'S APHORISMS:

Desire for ocean adventure is ailment very much like hives - give itch to many boys.

Man has learned much who has learned how to die.

Method sometimes hide in madness of practical joke.

Man with ear to keyhole betray excessive curiosity.

Trouble, like first love, teach many lessons.
 
Investigation best way to find answer.


OTHER WORTHY STATEMENTS:

(Miss Nodbury: "Are you looking for someone here?")  Yes. Number two son who have become number one problem child.

Have come to return young sea hawk to nest of college books. Same must hatch diploma before chasing wild goose.  (To Miss Nodbury regarding his son, Jimmy)

I came to search for black sheep and find only black cat.  (Regarding a black cat that startled Miss Nodbury)

May dreams of beauty and felicity fill your night.  (To Miss Nodbury)

Look for iron instrument, slightly damaged trying to crack hard nut.  (Regarding bump on Jimmy's head received in a struggle)
 
(Jimmy: "You're not going to swallow that story, are you?")  Swallow much, but digest little.

Evidence indicate number two son all wet, as usual.  (To Jimmy, who had fallen into the water, about his mistaken murder theory)

Poor fish better wiggle into dry clothing.  (To Jimmy)
 
(Jimmy: "You had your pocket picked on this ship?")  Have not been on other ship!
 
(Steve Daniels: "Who's hollering?")  Inimitable lung power of number two son.

(Inspector Vesey: "The kid's got a head on his shoulders.")  Very good news, if true.

(Jimmy: "Maybe you ought to lend me your gun, too.")  Bullet from killer much easier to take than bullet from number two son.

Will remove menace to navigation at once.  (About Jimmy, who has fallen, once again, into the water)

Save alibi for autobiography.  (To Jimmy)



REVIEW:

Variety, March 26, 1941

'Dead Men Tell' is a standard entry in the Charlie Chan series, carrying familiar ingredients of a couple of murders and a mystery over four portions of a map of buried treasure. It's a programmer that will get by as supporting fare in the houses where the Oriental detective built up a following with his crime deductions.

A schooner outfitted for a treasure hunt is the locale of Charlie's latest adventure. There's a murder of the trip's proponent, the arrival of Chan and the usual list of suspects among members of the crew and expedition, until Chan finally sets the trap for the real culprit. No. 2 son weaves in and out to assist the audience in tabbing the wrong suspect.

In order to set background of eerie situations, old schooner used is tabbed as a seagoing museum with old time relics aboard to give Chan a chance at weird settings for his wanderings aboard. Yarn sticks close to the Chan formula, but drags in too many suspects for general credulity.

The picture is a 'Grand Hotel' aboard the docked ship, and played close to the shore - with the four-piece map another familiar piece of story construction.



FILM NOTES:

PROBABLE DATE: Late 1940 ( December 1940?) (one night)
 
PROBABLE LOCATION: Port of Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California (Los Angeles Harbor - San Pedro)
 
TEXT OF THE SIGN ANNOUNCING THE TREASURE HUNT:
 
"BURIED
TREASURE
Dig for
$60,000,000
ON
COCOS ISLAND
JOIN THE
TREASURE HUNT
CRUISE
Aboard THE SUVA STAR" 
 
THE TIME, ACCORDING TO THE SHIP'S BELL OF THE SUVA STAR, AT THE BEGINNING OF THE FILM:  7:30 p.m. 
 
ACCORDING TO CAPTAIN KANE, WHEN THE SUVA STAR WAS TO SET SAIL FOR COCOS ISLAND: "We've gotta sail in the morning."
 
THE PERSONS WHO ORIGINALLY HAD THE IDEA FOR THE TREASURE HUNT: Miss Nodbury and Steve Daniels
 
CAPTAIN KANE'S "OLD SUPERSTITION" IN HIS OWN WORDS: "...I never meet my passengers until we're clear of port..."
 
IN CHARLIE CHAN'S WORDS, HIS CURRENT POSITION: "Am Lieutenant Chan of Honolulu Police."
 
ACCORDING TO CHARLIE CHAN, THE CLUES THAT POINTED TO SON JIMMY BEING ABOARD THE SUVA STAR: "...advertisement of treasure cruise plus missing toothbrush and pajamas..."
 
THE NUMBER OF PIECES THAT MISS NODBURY TORE THE TREASURE MAP: Four
 
THE PIRATES MENTIONED BY MISS NODBURY TO CHARLIE CHAN: Calico Jim, Romito the Bloody, and Matthew Nodbury ("Black Hook")
 
THE ANCIENT INSTRUMENT OF TORTURE ON DISPLAY ABOARD THE SUVA STAR: Iron maiden
 
MATTHEW NODBURY'S RELATIONSHIP TO MISS NODBURY: Grandfather
 
THE METHOD BY WHICH "BLACK HOOK" WAS EXECUTED FOR MURDER AND PIRACY "OVER A HUNDRED YEARS AGO": Hanging
 
THE TIME, ACCORDING TO THE SHIP'S BELL, AS CHARLIE CHAN LEFT MISS NODBURY: 8 p.m.
 
ACCORDING TO BILL LYDIG, THE DEPARTURE TIME FOR THE SUVA STAR: "...seven in the morning."
 
THE NEWSPAPER FOR WHICH BILL LYDIG WAS SUPPOSEDLY A REPORTER: The St. Louis Sun-Herald
 
WHEN, ACCORDING TO WHAT CHARLIE CHAN HAD HEARD, BILL LYDIG HAD BEEN "CALLED TO (HIS) ANCESTORS": "...six months ago."
 
BILL LYDIG'S DUBIOUS EXPLANATION TO CHARLIE CHAN, THE NAME OF HIS BROTHER, ALSO A REPORTER FOR THE SAME PAPER, WHO HAD DIED: "That was my brother Phil - Phil Lydig."
 
JED THOMASSON'S BUSINESS: Rare coins
 
THE HOME TOWN OF JED THOMASSON: Baltimore
 
KATE RANSOME'S PROFESSION, DETERMINED BY CHARLIE CHAN, DUE TO THE CONDITION OF HER FINGERTIPS: Typist (Charlie Chan: "Condition of fingertips peculiar to occupation.")
 
THE SEVERAL CLUES THAT POINTED TO "BLACK HOOK" AS THE CAUSE OF MISS NODBURY'S DEATH: Peg leg marks on the carpet, fresh scratches on the cabin door made by an iron hook, and a fragment of an imitation beard
 
THE HOME TOWN OF GENE LAFARGE: New Orleans, Louisiana 
 
THE PROBABLE TIME OF CHARLES AND LAURA THURSDAY'S WEDDING: About 5:30 p.m. (Charles Thursday: "...three [hours ago].")
 
CHARLES THURSDAY'S REAL LAST NAME: Parks
 
CHARLES THURSDAY'S PROFFESSION: Movie actor
 
THE HOME PORT OF THE SUVA STAR AS NOTED ON A LIFE PRESERVER: Tahiti
 
THE NAME OF THE SAILORS' CAFE LOCATED NEAR THE SUVA STAR: "Jim and Eddie's Place"
 
THE NAME OF THE PENNY ARCADE VIEWING MACHINE AT THE SAILORS' BAR: "The 'IT' Girl"
 
THE TYPE OF WOOD FROM WHICH THE PEG LEG OF THE SAILOR AT THE CAFE WAS MADE: Mahogany
 
THE NAME CALLED OUT BY THE DART-PLAYING SAILOR AT THE CAFE: Harry
 
THE NAME OF CAPTAIN KANE'S TALKING PARROT: Gertie
 
THE NAME ON THE SIGN NEAR THE REAR DOOR OF THE SAILORS' CAFE: "BARTEL"
 
DR. BONNEY'S DRINK AT THE SAILORS' CAFE: Coca-Cola (judging by the bottle's distinctive shape) 
 
DR. BONNEY'S PROFESSIONAL FIELD: Psychoanalysis
 
GENE LA FARGE'S PSYCHOLOGICAL PROBLEM, ACCORDING TO DR. BONNEY: "He suffers from an anxiety neuosis and a fear of facing unpleasant situations.  His impulse is to always run away from trouble."
 
LOCATION ABOARD THE SUVA STAR WHERE JIMMY CHAN FOUND THE "BLACK HOOK" COSTUME HIDDEN: In Steve Daniels' cabin, hidden under a a raincoat in the closet
 
ACCORDING TO THE SHIP'S BELL, THE TIME AS CHARLIE CHAN DISCOVERS THAT THE TREASURE MAP PIECES HAVE BEEN TAKEN FROM HIS COAT POCKET: 9:30 p.m.
 
THE TITLE AND SUB-TITLE OF THE MAGAZINE ARTICLE CONCERNING "BILL LYDIG":
 
"STILL AT
  LARGE"
 
"Law enforcement officers
throughout the nation are
seeking the convicted
murder and bank
robber who
escaped
from San
Quentin
Prison"
 
LYDIG'S PRISON IDENTIFICATION NUMBER: 95065
 
ACCORDING TO THE SHIP'S BELL, THE TIME AS JIMMY CHAN "WALKS THE PLANK": 10:30 p.m.
 
THE TEXT OF THE SIGN AT THE END OF THE PLANK: "ORIGINAL PIRATE PLANK"
 
THE CAUSE OF BILL LYDIG'S DEATH: Suffocation
 
THE WORDING OF THE SIGN ON THE OUTSIDE WALL OF THE BUILDING ON THE WHARF WHERE CAPTAIN KANE'S OFFICE WAS LOCATED: "SAIL LOFT"
 
THE TREASURE SOUGHT BY CAPTAIN KANE AND HIS ONE-TIME PARTNER THAT HAD ONCE LED THEM TO COCOS ISLAND: "The Treasure of Peru"
 
ACCORDING TO CAPTAIN KANE, THE MARKERS LEFT BY "BLACK HOOK" ON COCOS ISLAND: "Human skulls buried in the sand."
 
THE PERIODICAL THAT WAS BEING READ BY THE SERGEANT AT POLICE HEADQUARTERS, HOMICIDE DIVISION: Daily Police Bulletin
 
BESIDES CAPTAIN KANE AND JED THOMASSON, THE OTHER PERSON ON THE SUVA STAR WHO HAD BEEN TO COCOS ISLAND: Charles Thursday
 
ACCORDING TO THE SHIP'S BELL, THE TIME AS THE POLICE ALLOW THE ASSEMBLED SUSPECTS TO LEAVE THE 'SUVA STAR': 11 p.m.
 
THE DESTINATION OF THE PLANE CHARTERED BY JED THOMASSON: Panama
 
THE SCHEDULED TIME OF DEPARTURE FOR THE PLANE: Midnight
 
THE PERSONS WHO HAD EACH HELD A PIECE OF BLACK HOOK'S TREASURE MAP: Miss Nodbury, Gene LaFarge, Laura Thursday, and Jed Thomasson
 
THE NUMBER OF TIMES THAT JIMMY CHAN FELL INTO THE BAY: Four (twice from the sailors' cafe, once from the plank of the Suva Star, and once from the dock)
 
THE APROXIMATE TIME, BASED IN THE RINGING OF THE SHIP'S BELL OF THE SUVA STAR, AT THE END OF THE FILM:  Probably after 11:30 p.m.

 
 

GLOSSARY:

aft - At, in, toward, or close to the stern (rear) of a vessel.
Charlie Chan: "Who occupies cabins aft?"
 
belaying pin - A short, removable wooden or metal pin fitted in a hole in the rail of a boat and used for securing running gear.
Gene La Farge: "...I saw him trying to hit this young man with a belaying pin."
 
dough - (Slang)  Money.
Woman on Pier: "60 million bucks!  Boy, I didn't know there was that much dough in the whole world!"
 
Cocos Island - A small island owned by Costa Rica.  Cocos Island lies in the Pacific Ocean about 300 miles south of the Central American country.
Partial text on a poster: "...Dig for $60,000,000 ON COCOS ISLAND" 
                               
fo'c's'le (forecastle) - The upper deck of a ship in front of the foremast.
Charles Thursday: "[The music] seems to come from the fo'c's'le."
 
lubber - (1) A clumsy person.  (2) An inexperienced sailor: a landlubber.
Jed Thomasson: "I'm an awful lubber, I don't know one line from another."
 
numismatician (numatist) - A specialist in or a collector of coins and medals.
Charlie Chan: [referring to Jed Thomasson] "Numismatician."
 
ocarina - A small, simple wind instrument shaped like a sweet potato and usually made of terra cotta, with finger holesand a mouthpiece. 
Charlie Chan: "Have also heard music. Same comes from ocarina, favorite instrument of ancient pirates."
 
real McCoy - (Informal)  Authentic.
Bill Lydig: "Is it the real McCoy?" 
 
Suva - The capital of Fiji, on the southeast coast of Viti Levu.  It is a commercial and shipping center.
Partial text on a poster: "...CRUISE Aboard THE SUVA STAR"
 
For a complete list from all films, please visit our Charlie Chan Glossary. 

 
 

TIME AS INDICATED BY A SHIP'S BELL:

As viewers of "Dead Men Tell" have probably noted, the ship's bell of the sailing ship 'Suva Star' is rung with some regularity throughout the film.  The bell's ringing indicated the passage of time, and, as is the case aboard ships to this day, a bell is rung each half-hour to let those aboard know the currtent time, or, more specifically, the current time of a specific watch.
 
Aboard ship, a 24-hour day is divided into six periods of time called watches.  Each watch lasts for four hours, with the first watch beginning at midnight.  At the end ot the first half-hour of a particular watch, the bell is rung once ("ding").  A half-hour later, at the end of the first full hour, the bell is rung twice in succession ("ding-ding").  At the next half-hour, the sound would be: "ding-ding...ding," and so on, until, at the end of the watch, the bell rings a total of eight times: "ding-ding...ding-ding...ding-ding...ding-ding."
 
So, with this in mind, one can tell the time as indicated by the ship's bell of the 'Suva Star' as Charlie Chan solves this murder case.  At the beginning of the movie, the bell can be heard to ring seven times, which indicates that the current time, since it is nightime, is either 7:30 p.m. or 11:30 p.m.  Given the activity on and around the ship, we can safely say that the earlier time is correct, and we can go on from there, having an idea as to the time as the film progresses toward its conclusion, at around 11:30 that night!

 
 

COCOS ISLAND MAPS:

Yes, Cocos Island is an actual place! This small island is owned by Costa Rica, and lies in the Pacific Ocean about 300 miles south of the Central American country. Over the centuries, Cocos Island has seen its share of pirates and buried treasure.

moonrise2.gif

moonrise2.gif

 
 

Return to The Films of Charlie Chan

Return to Charlie Chan Family Home ENTRANCE